Guide · HOA paint colors · Estrella, Goodyear
Estrella HOA Repaint Requirements
By the Orange Coatings team · Published
Every exterior repaint in Estrella needs prior written approval from the Design Review Committee (DRC), even if you are repainting the original color, and only the pre-approved color schemes for your neighborhood are allowed. Original or existing colors that are not on the current schemes will not be approved, so an older home may have to change colors at its next repaint.
These requirements come from the Estrella Community Handbook (design guidelines, use regulations and rules), updated October 2026. Here is what they mean for a homeowner planning a repaint in this south Goodyear master plan.

| Who approves | Estrella Design Review Committee, managed by CCMC |
|---|---|
| Covers | House, trim, stucco walls and entry gates, original or new colors |
| Allowed colors | Pre-approved schemes for your neighborhood only |
| Required sheen | Flat on body, fascia and accents; flat or semi-gloss on doors |
| Review time | Up to 45 days by the handbook; the website says up to two weeks |
Which Estrella association are you in?
Estrella is a large lake-and-mountain master plan in south Goodyear, and owners belong to one of three associations: the Estrella Community Association, The Villages at Estrella Mountain Ranch Community Association, or the CantaMia Community Association for the gated 55+ village. CantaMia also runs its own design review page, which posts its approved schemes on the Sherwin-Williams HOA color archive and treats a repaint in the exact same scheme as maintenance that needs no submittal. Everywhere else, the handbook rules below apply.
CCMC manages the community, and design review requests go through its Design Review team at the Estrella Community Services office.
Original colors are not grandfathered
This is the rule that surprises people. To update the look of the community, the handbook says original and existing house colors will not be approved if they do not match the current pre-approved schemes for that neighborhood. Even if your home still wears its builder colors, you submit them for approval so the DRC can confirm they comply and update your lot file.
If your colors have been dropped, the repaint is the moment to move to a current scheme. Plan the choice early instead of discovering it after the application comes back.
How Estrella color schemes are organized
Approved schemes are kept at the Community Services office. Some neighborhoods also appear in the Dunn-Edwards Color Ark Pro library by parcel. The Las Palmas parcel of Estrella Mountain Ranch, for example, lists nine schemes, each naming a main body, garage door, fascia, pop-out, shutter and front door color, and pairing that scheme with a specific Eagle roof tile and, on some schemes, a brick veneer.
That pairing matters. The schemes were designed around the roof and masonry already on the house, so a scheme meant for a sandstone tile can look wrong over a brown one. Start with your roof tile color and narrow the list from there.
Placement, neighbor and sheen rules
- Identical or similar colors are not allowed on lots next to each other, and the DRC decides what counts as similar.
- Where a scheme allows accent-colored pop-outs, that applies to the front of the house only; side and rear pop-outs take the body color.
- No faux paint or faux finish on the body of the home.
- Body, fascia and accent colors must be flat.
- Garage and other exterior doors may be flat or semi-gloss.
- Stone and brick veneer may not be painted.
When an 8.5 x 11 sample is required
Three situations call for a physical sample: repainting the original color, living in a custom home subdivision, or using a paint manufacturer other than the one on file. In those cases you include an 8.5 by 11 inch sample of each color, with the manufacturer, color code and name, plus a color photo marking exactly where each sample goes on the house, fascia, pop-outs and garage door.
The DRC can also ask for a larger sample painted on the house or garage door before it decides. If you plan to use Sherwin-Williams on a scheme written in another brand, assume samples will be requested and prepare them up front.
Walls and gates count too
Stucco walls and entry gates are covered by the same approval rule as the house. On lots visible from neighboring property, open space, lakes or golf course parcels, privately owned exterior walls must at least be painted, and approved wall color schemes for each subdivision are held at the management company's office. Painting any wall, including your side of a property line wall, needs prior written DRC approval.
Submitting a repaint request
- Confirm which association governs your lot and get your neighborhood's approved schemes from Community Services.
- Choose a scheme that suits your roof tile and differs from the homes on either side.
- Start a Design Review request through the online forms on the Life in Estrella website.
- Attach a color photo of the front of the home and a scope of work describing every surface to be painted.
- Add 8.5 x 11 samples and a marked-up photo if your situation requires them.
- Wait for written approval. Silence is not approval; the handbook gives the DRC up to 45 days to respond.
How we handle an Estrella repaint
We start by finding your scheme and roof tile pairing, then list each scheme color with its Sherwin-Williams match and the sheen the handbook requires for that surface. You get a written scope that names every surface, which is also what the Design Review request asks for.
On the house, we wash, fix cracks, prime bare or patched stucco with Loxon and apply two coats of Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior, using a flat finish on the body, fascia and accents.

Frequently asked questions
- Do I need approval to repaint my Estrella home its original color?
- Yes. The handbook requires DRC approval for any exterior color application, original or new, and original colors must still match a current pre-approved scheme.
- Can I use satin paint on my Estrella house?
- Not on the body, fascia or accents, which must be flat. Garage and other exterior doors may be flat or semi-gloss.
- How long does Estrella design review take?
- The handbook gives the DRC up to 45 days to respond, while the Life in Estrella website says approval could take up to two weeks. Plan for the longer number.
- Can my Estrella home be the same color as my neighbor's?
- No. Identical or similar colors are not allowed on lots next to each other, and the DRC decides what counts as similar.
- Where do I find Estrella's approved color schemes?
- At the Estrella Community Services office. Some parcels also appear in the Dunn-Edwards Color Ark Pro library, listed by neighborhood name.
- Do you paint homes in CantaMia?
- Yes. CantaMia is inside Estrella in Goodyear, which we serve. Its approved schemes are on the Sherwin-Williams HOA archive, and a new scheme goes to its Design Review Committee with photos of the homes beside and across from yours.