Orange Coatings LLC · (602) 932-3417 · Get an estimate

Guide · Paint products

Dunn-Edwards vs Sherwin-Williams for Arizona Homes

By the Orange Coatings team · Published

For an Arizona house, Dunn-Edwards and Sherwin-Williams are both good choices, and the gap between their top exterior lines is much smaller than the gap between a top line and a bargain one from either brand. Pick the premium tier, prime bare stucco properly and apply two full coats, and either brand will outlast a cheap paint job.

We use Sherwin-Williams on every job, so we are not neutral, but Dunn-Edwards is a well-regarded Southwest brand and we will be fair about it. Here is how the two compare on the things that matter in the West Valley.

Paint tray and five-gallon bucket set on a drop cloth before a job
Paint tray and five-gallon bucket set on a drop cloth before a job

The two companies in brief

Dunn-Edwards started in 1925 as a wallpaper business and opened its first paint factory in 1937. It has always been a regional brand focused on the Southwest, and says its paints are formulated for the climate there, from desert heat to the coast. It also runs a large production and distribution plant in Phoenix that it reports is LEED Gold certified.

Sherwin-Williams is a national manufacturer with a much broader product range, from house paint to industrial, floor and concrete coatings. In the Phoenix metro both brands have their own stores, so contractors and homeowners can get either one tinted locally.

Matching the lines tier by tier

Comparing brand to brand is less useful than comparing the right products. Here is roughly how the exterior lines line up, based on how each manufacturer positions them.

  • Dunn-Edwards Evershield: the company's ultra-premium 100% acrylic exterior line, marketed for UV fade resistance and resistance to peeling, blistering, efflorescence and alkali burn on masonry and stucco.
  • Sherwin-Williams Emerald Exterior: Sherwin-Williams' premium exterior, sold as a self-priming paint that resists fading, blistering, peeling, dirt pickup and mildew.
  • Dunn-Edwards Spartashield: a premium 100% acrylic exterior line one step down, promoted for hide, flow and efflorescence resistance.
  • Sherwin-Williams Duration and SuperPaint: strong mid-to-upper tier lines that we compare against Emerald when a budget calls for it.

What actually decides how long paint lasts in Arizona

In our climate the enemies are ultraviolet light, heat cycling and monsoon water. A 100% acrylic binder handles all three better than cheaper vinyl-acrylic blends, and both brands use 100% acrylic in their premium exteriors. After that, the biggest factors are not the label at all.

Prep and film build decide most failures we see. Chalky walls that were not washed, cracks that were not filled, bare stucco that was not primed, and a single thin coat will sink any brand. Color matters too: deep, saturated colors fade faster than light ones under the same sun, whichever can they come out of.

Primers for stucco and masonry

Both companies sell masonry primers made for alkaline surfaces like new stucco, patch material and block. On our jobs, bare or patched stucco gets Sherwin-Williams Loxon masonry primer before the finish coats. If you go with Dunn-Edwards, use the masonry primer that company recommends under its topcoat rather than mixing brands, because each manufacturer tests its primers and finish coats as a system.

Windows wrapped in plastic, ladder and drop cloth along a siding wall before exterior painting
Windows wrapped in plastic, ladder and drop cloth along a siding wall before exterior painting

Colors and HOA palettes

This is where the brand question comes up most in the West Valley. Many HOA communities publish approved color schemes, and each scheme is usually written in one manufacturer's color names and numbers. Some palettes list Dunn-Edwards colors; others list Sherwin-Williams.

Paint stores can mix a color from another brand's formula, so a palette color can usually be matched in either brand. The catch is that a match is close, not always identical, especially in deep colors. Before a whole house is painted in a cross-matched color, put a sample on the wall and check it beside the HOA chip in daylight. If your HOA requires a specific brand, follow the written rule.

Why we standardize on Sherwin-Williams

Sticking with one manufacturer means our painters already know how every product behaves in the sprayer, under the back-roller and in 110-degree heat. It keeps color matching consistent from one job to the next, and it means every homeowner gets the same spec. Our standard on stucco is Loxon on bare or patched areas, then two coats of Emerald Exterior, sprayed and back-rolled.

That is a choice about consistency, not a claim that Dunn-Edwards falls short. A homeowner who has a Dunn-Edwards color they love, or an HOA palette in Dunn-Edwards colors, can still get a great result; we would cross-match the color and confirm it with a sample first.

How to choose between them

  1. Check your HOA rules for a required brand or a palette written in one brand's colors.
  2. Choose the top exterior tier of whichever brand you use for sun-facing stucco walls.
  3. Use that same brand's masonry primer on bare or patched stucco.
  4. Ask your painter which brand their crew uses every day; familiarity with a product affects the finish.
  5. Compare estimates by product line, number of coats and prep, not by brand name alone.

Frequently asked questions

Is Dunn-Edwards better than Sherwin-Williams for desert heat?
Neither is clearly better across the board. Dunn-Edwards builds its brand around Southwest conditions, and Sherwin-Williams' top exterior lines are also made for harsh sun; the premium tiers of both perform well when the prep is done right.
Can a Dunn-Edwards color be made in Sherwin-Williams paint?
Usually, yes. Stores can mix a color from another brand's formula, and the result is typically very close. Always check a painted sample on your wall before committing, particularly for dark or saturated colors.
Which is the Dunn-Edwards equivalent of Emerald Exterior?
Evershield is Dunn-Edwards' ultra-premium exterior line, so it is the closest comparison to Emerald Exterior. Spartashield sits a tier below it.
Does my painter's brand choice affect the result?
It does, mostly through familiarity. A crew that uses one product line every day knows its spray settings, dry times and quirks, and that shows up in the finish.
Do you ever use Dunn-Edwards paint?
Our standard is Sherwin-Williams on every job. If your HOA palette is written in Dunn-Edwards colors, we match those colors in Sherwin-Williams products and confirm the match with a sample.
Should I mix brands of primer and paint?
It is better not to. Each manufacturer tests its own primers under its own topcoats, so staying in one brand keeps the system predictable.

Related

Sources